Pigeon Cay Beach Club

  • Cat Island, The Bahamas

Pigeon Cay is located on Cat Island in the Bahamas, a 48 miles long, lush, and hilly island with warm inviting people. Laid back and casual, it offers the traveler a taste of paradise only experienced from a lucky few who have come here before.

Pigeon Cay is a small private property where personalized service for each guest is a priority. Pigeon Cay is situated on one of the most beautiful beaches in the Bahamas in the Northern area of Cat Island, 3 miles south of Bennetts Harbor.

Complimentary fruit basket in your cottage upon arrival. Breakfast lunch and dinner available to guest that want to be catered to, served to you in your cottage, room service style or outdoor dinning at the beach.
Pigeon Cay is a newer version of its former self. The site used to be home to a 10 room hotel that was open in 1968 which burned down in 1972. The property sat until the current owners Ned and Leslie bought it in 1992 and moved to Cat Island from Colorado in 1994.

It took three years to clean up and rebuild the beginnings of the beach club. A continuing labor of love that keeps Pigoen Cay evolving and guest returning year after year Guests return to Pigeon Cay because of the beauty and peace of the resort and they feel like they are coming home to be a part of the Pigeon Cay family.